Till Basfeld

Post-contractual non-compete obligation must not cover all activities for a competitor

In an indicative ruling dated August 02, 2018, the Higher Regional Court Munich (docket number 7 U 2107/18) has found that a post-contractual restraint which prohibited a managing director from working for a competitor in any way was invalid due to the lack of legitimate interests of the company. The managing director was therefore able to legitimately claim the invalidity of the non-compete obligation in the form of a preliminary injunction. The indicative ruling is …

Post-contractual non-compete obligation must not cover all activities for a competitor Read More »

Act of defiance or effective waiver of rights?

Due to the compulsory compensation payments, post-contractual non-competes are only common in Germany with regard to key employees with significant knowledge of the employer’s business or close client relationships. However, they are quite often the subject matter of legal disputes. Just recently the Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht, BAG) has ruled on the question of the effective revocation of a non-compete (31 January 2018; docket number: 10 AZR 392/17). In the case at hand, the plaintiff …

Act of defiance or effective waiver of rights? Read More »

Peak performances of professional soccer player up to retirement not to be expected

In February 2016 we reported on a ruling of the Higher Labour Court Rheinland-Pfalz (Landesarbeitsgericht, LAG) in regard to a case of a goalkeeper who sued his former Bundesliga soccer club for unlimited employment and payment of missed bonuses (https://blogs.dlapiper.com/employmentgermany/2016/02/18/no-second-bosman-total-relief-at-bundesliga/). Almost two years later, the Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht, BAG) has now confirmed on 16 January 2018 (docket-number: 7 AZR 312/16), that the established practice of employing professional soccer players only on a fixed-term basis …

Peak performances of professional soccer player up to retirement not to be expected Read More »

Minimum wage also applies to public holidays and night work premiums

Remuneration on public holidays, as well as night work premiums, which are based on the actual hourly earnings must be calculated at least on the basis of the minimum wage. This is the result of a new judgment by the Federal Labour Court dated 20 September 2017 (docket number 10 AZR 171/16). In the case at hand, the collective bargaining agreement provided for a night work premium amounting to 25% of the actual hourly earnings, and remuneration for …

Minimum wage also applies to public holidays and night work premiums Read More »

Suspicion of pretended sickness and activities for a competing company generally justified surveillance by a detective and immediate termination for cause

A new judgment of the Federal Labour Court (dated 29.6.2017, docket number 2 AZR 597/16) supports previous judgments concerning termination based on suspicion of breach of duties and furthermore sheds  light on the permissibility of carrying out surveillance on employees through a detective to clarify such suspicions. In the case at hand the employee and employer argued about the effectiveness of an extraordinary dismissal. The employee was repeatedly certified unfit to work in 2014 and …

Suspicion of pretended sickness and activities for a competing company generally justified surveillance by a detective and immediate termination for cause Read More »